Advertisement
Hello, I am organizing a retreat to Peru for two weeks in August. It is a little bit different than some of the other retreats that are offered in that I will also be presenting some workshops. These workshops will be on shamanism and shamanic healing techniques based upon the common principles and practices of shamanism. If you are interested in checking it out, information can be found here:
www.myspace.com/plantspiritmedicine
www.myspace.com/plantspiritmedicine
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Thu, May 28, 2009 - 2:33 PMon the one hand, i respect and honor your effort to benefit people and their health. i think it's wonderful to (i'm assuming this is what you decided to do) dedicate yourself to service for the health and well being of others. i admire this in anybody and wish you many blessings in this regard. i hope your good work may benefit many.
On the other hand, this appears disrespectful on so many levels, foremost is the great need in Peru directly resulting from our enormous footprint, the great need for the tradition and lineage to be preserved in the Amazon, to save the medicine plants, to keep the jungle in tact.
it disrespects the fully able curanderos who LIVE in the jungle and serve their communities who cannot always pay. if you truly truly LOVE la medicina Amazonas then devote yourself to Pachamama without ego or personal agenda. give yourself to Her. She has obviously been very generous with you or you would not have put yourself out there as an advocate for Her healing power and wisdom.
something to consider.
stay strong.
many blessings to us all for our strength, bravado and vigilance in facing ourselves with total honesty. and for our awakening.
(may there be an end of suffering and enlightenment for ALL sentient beings without exception) -
-
Unsu...
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Thu, May 28, 2009 - 9:20 PMi agree that preserving the amazon is absolutely necessary. although i don's personally feel drawn to this particular opportunity, i don't see how this agenda is actually disrespecting anyone, atleast not by what i read in the post or on the website.
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Thu, May 28, 2009 - 10:41 PMIt does seem Embrace like maybe you jumped out of the gate pretty quick on this one, cause I gotta admit that I didn't really understand your perspective in relation to the original post. Maybe a couple more words on exactly why this retreat is disrespectful, more so than any other retreat like these that people plan? Not attacking, just honestly curious.
:)
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Thu, May 28, 2009 - 11:11 PMguess i'm about to stir up that tired old yet lively discussion regarding the work of people in their own traditions and the work of people borrowing from others' traditions.
it's one thing to be inspired by a people and their knowledge and practices to utilize a bit of that knowledge for the benefit of many others for selfless reasons, including hoping that through that dedication ones family is provided for. but to go there and set up shop? as a young white guy?
what would impress me is having set up a program by which the money made from his effort, beyond recompense to support the community in some way, not by employing them, by providing education and resources for them to provide for themselves. something to bring us all forward.
is the curendera an employee? if not then why is he promoting himself as a shaman? whose money built the place? it's all very odd and makes me wonder how anyone is going to trust my white face walking up.
the traditional folks there don't call themselves shaman. this is an imported ego trip.
maybe i'm only projecting my own frustration with the enormous differences between our cultures and
mis-understanding mostly by the northerners and distrust in the south toward us. and these entrepreneurial ventures in the amazon to catch a little of that ayahuasca tourism dollar of which there are plenty.
i pray that we always make our choices for the wider benefit. carry our own cup and water, design sustainably with renewable resources, give ourselves toward preserving or providing safe and healthy lives for all beings.
i pray for blessings for the people and traditions of the Amazon (and entire world) that they will continue their lineage and knowledge about the plant medicine and curandismo. which may amount to our halting our dependence on the products made from the rainforest which by extracting force the people there away from their homes in the forest where their food, medicine, shelter and knowledge come from.
oops, tangent. self-righteous arrogant soap box moment. like a kodac moment only inexcusable!
i also pray that the most brilliant among us together create and implement multiple designs for transition culture and beyond.
just start doing something. especially those of us continuously drawn to Her. that's a very large fuel print. let us make it count for something, anything. we can start simply and build on that then we will see it all has already begun to change toward our collective benefit by individual effort. nothing exist alone in this world. everything is part of its own and ever widening cycles. our eyes and minds must open so we can see clearly what we are doing, the impact, implication, effect of our own and others lives.
oops, sorry. i better go ...
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 7:47 AMEmbrace, I have to admit, I dont really know how to respond to your post. I can appreciate your concern for the local people, environment, and all of the other things you have written about, but it seems to me that you have made a bit of a knee jerk reaction. First of all, nowehere have I ever stated that I am a shaman. Yes, I am a shamanic practicioner and have made it my way of life. It seems to me that you are accusing me of taking advantage of my teacher. Whose money built the place? Well, of course the people who go to see her. Is she an employee? Of course not, she is my teacher and friend and I want to share her knowledge of health and healing with others. I think that you said it best yourself that you are projecting your own frustrations, and I feel the same way with some of what you have stated. The preservation of the traditions and culture is important to me, but you have not even asked me what I am doing to help improve the community, you have just made a blanket statement about me and what my intentions are. I think your comments belong to a different post as your comments have nothing to do with the retreat that I am organizing. So, I dont really want to engage in trying to convince you of my good intentions; it doesnt really matter anyways. You will have your opinion regardless of what I write here. You do make some valid points, but place them in the appropriate post. Peace on you. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 7:58 AM"It seems to me that you are accusing me of taking advantage of my teacher. Whose money built the place? Well, of course the people who go to see her. Is she an employee? Of course not, she is my teacher and friend and I want to share her knowledge of health and healing with others. I think that you said it best yourself that you are projecting your own frustrations ... "
so glad you were able to post a response.
your teacher whose place it is? is not very clear in the presentation. this curandera has taught you and does business with you and you have only her photo (and not flattering, and as a student myself i always present the best photo possible of my teacher because i love and respect his work so much). i still do not see humility or respect in your promotion. a lot of posed photos of you with the items of your craft. the attention is on you rather than the curandera, her place, and the tradition and medicine.
as i said earlier, i respect and honor the work. i'm just not diggin on what you have presented as what you do. guess very personal. a bit fierce because I'm growing impatient. so many brilliant people called to la medicina and i seldom hear about very clear benefitial results for the people and communities there.
it saddens me. so please, please do tell us what you are doing for the community. and what about this teacher? who is she, where is she and her people?
i would love to hear about what you are doing for the community! very much. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 3:33 PMAs stated in my web page, this retreat is in association with the ayahuasca foundation. All information can be found there, ayahuascafoundation.org/
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 8:12 AMMJ --
Here is what your MySpace page says:
"A little information about myself,I have been a practitioner and student of shamanism for over 10 years. I am currently in my third year of a shamanic coaching program, and have recently completed the ayahuayra curandero initiation program. I have also completed some courses at the Michael Harners institute of Shamanic Studies."
I would be very interested to learn more about the shamanic coaching program -- what it consists of, where it is held, who teaches it, what you have learned. I would also like to learn about the Ayahuayra curandero initiation -- how were you initiated? what healing techniques did you learn? what plant medicines do you use? And which of the Michael Harner courses have you completed?
You say that "Participants will receive plant remedies to completely heal any and all afflictions." That is a large claim. Do you claim to be able to cure, say, breast cancer? Can you cure glioblastoma multiforme?
In your post you say, "I will also be presenting some workshops. These workshops will be on shamanism and shamanic healing techniques based upon the common principles and practices of shamanism." What workshops will you be presenting?
I am impressed that you see yourself as a teacher after only ten years. I would really like to learn more about your training and background.
I should add that you suddenly appeared on this tribe, with no picture, no friends, no prior interaction, apparently for the sole purpose of advertising your retreat. You should not be surprised that people do not respond with enthusiasm. I think that people would take you much more seriously if you had spent some time contributing to the discussions here, letting people learn about your skills and knowledge from their ongoing interactions with you.
Still, I am eager to hear more about where you are coming from and what you are offering.
-- Steve
singingtotheplants.blogspot.com/
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 10:27 AMWell, first I want to say that I know that I am a new peron on this site (fairly...) and I am promoting this retreat, but I dont really post much on this site as I usually follow a different forum, which I have been a member of for a few years. I wrote about the coaching program in a post below, which you can look at your own leisure. It is held in Canada. Here is the site if you want to check it out yourself. www.shamanicmedicine.ca I myself am not claiming to heal cancer, my teacher is the one who can do that. She has cured breast cancer, both for herself and others. I know this for a fact because one of her patients, presently with Donna Othelia, is with her, and I was with her as well. I dont know what glioblastoma multiforme is... As for the workshops I will be presenting, I thought I explained them on the site, but here is a recap, and I guess a bit more of an explination. The medicine wheel workshop (one of them) will teach about how to connect with all of the energies of the earthly and spiritual realms, known as the Earth count. This ceremony is to awaken the connection of the energy within and helps to allow you to be a natural and integral part of life itself. The other workshop is on power animals and guides. With this workshop, we will look at our chief power animal, and our birth animal and investigate what they are. A guided journey will taught, and with this journey the participants will find out which animals they are. The last workshop is on assemblage points. The assemblage point of humans is a pinpoint of energy and light located in the centre of the chest just above the level of the nipples. Balanced feelings, balanced reason, balanced mind are concidered a perception of reality from a balanced frame of reference. We will also examine maladaptive assemblage points, and how we can centre ourselves. I know you asked other questions, but quite frankly, I have been posting responses on this site for the past 3 hours, and a bit tired of writing. Will write some more later. I appreciate the forums criticisms, and welcome all feedback. Thank you.
-
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 12:01 AMEmbrace,
First let me say I’ve read about your work with the children of Iquitos and I share many of the frustrations you express about the inequalities of life there. I admire your work tremendously!
I do feel you have attacked this young man unfairly.
Do you seek a world of compassionate love and understanding? Then why do you withhold these very gifts from this man whose stated purpose is to be in service to others and their healing. Perhaps a gentile guiding hand is more in order.
Truly, “our eyes and minds must open so we can see clearly what we are doing, the impact, implication, effect of our own and others lives.”
Abrazos grandes,
David -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 7:19 AM"I do feel you have attacked this young man unfairly.
Do you seek a world of compassionate love and understanding? Then why do you withhold these very gifts from this man whose stated purpose is to be in service to others and their healing. Perhaps a gentile guiding hand is more in order.
Truly, “our eyes and minds must open so we can see clearly what we are doing, the impact, implication, effect of our own and others lives.”
hi david,
i do indeed see the world with compassion and understanding (i realize you said seek but i don't seek it it is already here! lol)! i also stand by everything i said. everything. none with malice or ill will toward this young man. i feel it needs to be said. maybe he will think more carefully about his presentation. maybe he will find a bit of respect and humility or think about it. maybe he will SAY his teachers name, explain who she is. talk about her people, the forest, the medicine. maybe he will see it is not about him though he makes it appear so.
i can assure you that there is compassion behind all of this. with all my heart and with compassion i point out these things, not with anger or ill will of any kind.
look closely at my words, you will see.
you all might deny this but you and i are conditioned and indoctrinated to think and behave and perceive in a particular way. we do not truly see the people and amazon, or anything else for that matter, as they are. we only see through this filtration. it takes great effort, care and time to peel or shed the layers of programming especially if we continue our patterning and lives here because everything reinforces our programming on conscious and mostly unconscious levels. if there is any chance of preserving the forest and the traditions, medicine, etc. we truly must begin with here and work toward opening our eyes. for those willing, have patience and be vigilant.
all the best to you, david. good point made. good heart that made it.
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 11:12 AMdavid, by the way, thank you for your kind words but i have to say that personally i have not done anything of significance.
i have, however, built the means by which you or anyone who is compelled, can themselves do something (large or small) of significance. amazonistas.org is designed to make it possible and a simple pleasure to do something meaningful for people or the amazon which give so very much to you without expectation. it is quite easy to return in some fashion some of that good.
-
-
-
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 7:23 AMactually, i do not feel at all apologetic. the image alone (young white guy with traditional curandero accouterments) offends. -
-
Unsu...
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 8:07 AMok i am starting to understand a little bit...
on one hand, i also get a little whincy when i see white guys wearing the feather crowns, and shipibo clothing, for example..
because in one way it can be a total mockery. it's not our culture and there are many things that this clothing represents that we white folks may never understand...
but in another way,
if you've gone thru the appropriate training to facilitate, it only makes sense to wear the clothing that others with the same or similar "status" wears. you've earned it.
other thoughts?
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 8:08 AMEmbrace I think you're being a little bit unfair and venting frustrations from your life onto our friend here. Now, I don't know anything about his intentions but nothing that he's said indicates to me what you are accusing him of. Plus, you know white people are allowed to hold Shakapas right? My Maestro is white as can, Euro-American just like me, and well, I'm not gonna get into a "My Curandero is better than your Curandero" argument, but of the many that I've sat with only one was better: his teacher (Don Solon).
So anyways........ -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 8:22 AMright, jav, you are pointing to the lineage of what you were taught. that demonstrates a certain amount of respect (which hints at humility). and you mentioned Don Solon's name which shows respect for his work.
definitely the ferocity of my response is the result of frustration, jav and mj, no doubt about it. the forest and people/traditions are threatened. it is not a casual matter. it's not like it can wait for other lifetimes, folks.
-
Unsu...
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 8:23 AMembrace we also need to be reminded that your responsibility with the medicine is very unique,
not everyone is being asked by the mother to work directly with the indigenous communities as passionately as you do,
some are asked to be a part of the evolution of the medicine,
some do both...
it's a delicate balance.
with that said, i, too would like to know more about MJ's experience and background.
MJ, as you can tell, some of us have been in this forum for a long time, and a certain element of trust (sortof) has been built...forgive us for taking all you say with a grain of salt, because as im sure you know there are alot of fakers out there and that just, well, really pisses us off. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 8:35 AM"embrace we also need to be reminded that your responsibility with the medicine is very unique,
not everyone is being asked by the mother to work directly with the indigenous communities as passionately as you do, "
very true. but we certainly all must concern ourselves and pay attention to what we are doing. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 8:48 AM
I understand people feel called to work with the medicine in different ways as Rebecca said, but I also really see Embraces points about relationship. How you're relating to the culture whose teaching set you on a path of participation with it's medicines and healing modality says a lot about you as a person. Almost zero information about the curandero?
"Heal any and all afflictions" ??? .........
That's a completely over the top statement and unacceptable in my point of view. If you make a statement like that you should be prepared to back it up with some serious fieldwork credentials and verifiable experience. You would need testimonials from a percentage of all those healed that can be verified at the very least. No reasonable, qualified, or professional person would make a statement like that, it's ridiculous, and if your claims are ridiculous then so are you on some important level. -
-
with teeth bared
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 8:57 AM"Heal any and all afflictions" ??? .........
That's a completely over the top statement and unacceptable in my point of view. "
and very dangerous. especially for people with serious medical and/or psychological conditions. we hear story after story of tragic outcomes, right?
some here think i'm only being ferocious because of the people. i'm fired up over a lot more than that, believe me. lol -
-
Re: with teeth bared
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 9:42 AMYes, I make that statement because the curandero's I have worked with have cured cancer, aids, and many other aflictions and health concerns. Two weeks may not be long enough for some and may require a longer treatment time, but in my experince, health does occur. Perhaps this statement that I wrote should be rewritten, so thank you for this. But let me add here that a persons capacity and willingness to heal is up to them. I cannot comment on what you said about stories of tragic outcomes, I have no knowlege of them or about the person trying to heal them. Perhaps they healed their soul and was able to leave this world with pleasure, love and self awareness. Who knows. Death happens. Do you know those people's journey or know of their stories personally? Do you know if they were able to stand strong before their death? Did those people take full responsibility for their problem, that they accept that it is possible to heal and cure their illness? I dont know that, and neither do you. But I understand you being fired up over the statement made. I know that health can occur. I know that healing can occur. If that satement is over the top for you, then thats fine. You dont have to believe if you dont want to. -
-
Re: with teeth bared
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 10:11 AM
"Yes, I make that statement because the curandero's I have worked with have cured cancer, aids, and many other aflictions and health concerns. "
Worked with how? Assisted in the healing? In what way? Curandero's? Who? Which curendero's are currently curing aids and cancer?
And again, to make statements like that without any verifiable testimonials and notes on the healing process from the curendero's about how it was accomplished is RIDICULOUS.
I'm not saying healing isn't possible. I'm saying your way of promoting and discussing it is batty.
"But let me add here that a persons capacity and willingness to heal is up to them."
But of course! That's a marvelous statement to let you off the hook.
Healing is a dance between people in relationship.
I built a 50 story temple in the middle of the desert in two weeks, and if you don't believe it that's your problem. I don't have any blueprints or pictures and I can't tell you the names of the people who worked on it or how exactly we did it, but we really did it.
Cool huh.
-
Re: with teeth bared
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 10:14 AMMJ --
Thank you for the information on your background and training, as well as your clarification of the claim that your maestro can cure every disease.
I think I am now in a position to make a reasonably good judgment about the retreat that you are offering.
-- Steve
singingtotheplants.blogspot.com/
-
modalities
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 1:37 PMby the way, aron, you are looking very youthful for your age. you look like a kid to me! lol
"But let me add here that a persons capacity and willingness to heal is up to them. I cannot comment on what you said about stories of tragic outcomes, I have no knowlege of them or about the person trying to heal them. Perhaps they healed their soul and was able to leave this world with pleasure, love and self awareness. Who knows. Death happens."
this is a chilling statement, aron, and essentially a disclaimer. let's face our end straight on, indeed. i hardly think people are traveling there for their death, especially since it is promoted as a potential for healing. more like a cry for life thus - safety. you no doubt know basic first aid like cpr, that sort of thing? such a lackadaisical attitude about people's lives give's me the shivers.
respect and honor death, yes indeed, but please be intensely certain you are well equipped and prepared to do anything to save a life.
we are aware of the power for healing in the medicine plants in the amazon with the traditional knowledge practiced and taught along blood lines. they have lived for generations in the jungle with these plants. i wonder if they are wanting and need the assistance of other "modalities?"
why not work to enhance and further what she does? you can have the same amount of pleasure in it. who are these people there in that community? you can build something involving her that will benefit the community as well as offer travelers ceremonies and treatments like at her center as a means for paying for itself. make it possible for her to treat anyone in the community who are unable to pay. have you communicated with them? you likely have friends there by now? do they have a plant medicine pharmacy or clinic? do they want one? she would benefit by having both things, serving the community and guests at the community clinic and her own clients in her place?
throwing it out there.
or something
i say this with my heart wide open to you, brother. we all have a way to go before enlightenment, eh? lol
let us take special care along the way. and my heart is telling you to make a very careful assessment of what you are presenting/messaging. in there also question yourself regarding intent, brought up by jav.
only i know my true intention. same for us all.
-
-
-
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 9:17 AMAlright then, I shall try to provide more info. for you as requested. I dont know how much of a background you want from me, but ill keep it to my experence with being in Peru. By the way embrace, thank you for calling me young,as I feel young despite others teasing me about being 38... My first experience with the medicine was more than 6 years ago when I went to visit with Don Agustin Rivas. I wont go into details with my experiences with him, but lets just say that I didnt really understand the medicine very well, but I became drawn to it. Im sure many of you can relate to that experience. Since then, I have tried to come down to Peru to learn from the medicine, to heal myself physically, mentally and spiritually. More recently, I particilated in the Ayahuayra curandero initiation program through the ayahuasca foundation's school of curanderismo, where I learned to use certian tools, like the chakapa. My teacher is Donna Othelia, a very gentle healer and wonderful woman. I have also been learning about shamanic practices for the past 10 years or so. Part of it includes learning from the Michael Harner'sfoundation of shamanic studies (learned from Sharon Van Raalte) I am also taking a shamanic coaching course through the institute of shamanic medicine. I am in my third year of that program. After being with Othelia, and through long debates with myself about stepping into the role of becoming a healer (which I wont go into right now... but im sure many of you have had similar experiences of trying to become an authentic human being) I have been inspirted to share my gifts and experiences by organizing a retreat to become healthy with the assistance of Donna Othelia. And since I have a background with shamanic studies, I wanted to offer something more than just an ayahuasca retreat, I want to teach what I have been learning for the past 10 years. It has been my experience, at least observing other participants at many ceremonies I have attended, that many dont know how to protect themselves, or what to do. I am offering myself as a guide to help facilitate balance and wholeness using shamanic modalities, shamanic healing techniques, ceremony and ritual as a holistic approach to wellness. Now, you may wonder what is a shamanic coach. It is a person who encourages the inner journey, a person who helps others to define their intital intent or goals, encourages self-responsibility, facilitates the shamanic undertaking into the unconscious unknowing, a facilitator or shamanic knowledge, ceremonial process, and ritual, someone who uses shamanic techniques and tools to foster transformation and spiritual development. Mostly, a shamanic coach supports and fosterts the movement of evolution in co-creation with the person. These are the things I have and are learning. So is that enough for you? Can you understand my background a bit and know where I am comming from? So, either this retreat interests you, or not. I dont want to have to feel like I have to defend myself or convince you of my intents. I come from a place of wanting to help in other's health and healing, and I know that donna Othelia is an excellent curendera to help facilitate it. I am merely adding to her healing by teaching something more, something that once can continue to practice when one returns home. I hope this answers your question well enough. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 5:05 PMMJ-
If your Elders are alright with what you're doing, and believe you're qualified to do this work, then that's enough.
Sure, it's not the coolest thing in the world to show up to a forum with no history, no picture, no friends and just start advertising. That naturally draws some skepticism and flack. (And frankly, I understand why.)
But, in the end, you don't have to defend yourself to anyone but your Elders. If you're right with them, then right on.
Maybe you can branch out beyond this thread, and share some of your experiences with the medicine. I'm sure you have plenty to share, and it's probably a way more interesting discussion to have than this one.
That said, I appreciate the way you've responded to the various replies here. You've been kinder and more patient than a lot of folks would. That alone should make your Elders proud.
Best wishes,
Veg -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 11:59 AMthank you for your kind words. I appreciate it. I know I havent been on this forum very long (a few months), I just like to read the posts more than anything else... I will later think about writing some of my experiences.
-
-
-
-
-
-
blessings to mj and his teacher may their work benefit many
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 8:58 AMand harm none -
-
Unsu...
Re: blessings to mj and his teacher may their work benefit many
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 9:11 AMpoint take, CG.
i'm presently being confronted with the fear that this discussion will turn into another name-calling, "i know more about ayahuasca than you do" banter at which point i will gracefully cease to participate.
-
-
Re: blessings to mj and his teacher may their work benefit many
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 9:15 AMSorry Rebecca, I don't mean to imply any great knowledge about ayahuasca or start a conversation about who in particular is a better healer.
This seems more like a discussion of the ethical responsibilities of practitioners, what's appropriate to claim about the healing services and why.
-
Re: blessings to mj and his teacher may their work benefit many
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 9:23 AM"i'm presently being confronted with the fear that this discussion will turn into another name-calling, "i know more about ayahuasca than you do" banter at which point i will gracefully cease to participate."
i agree, not the tone i had meant to set. let's all be grateful. when we are grateful we are also happy for the others and their blessings too.
i imagine if we were to learn about the curandera/teacher at this center for healing we would find she does very good work. she certainly has set up the place very nicely. no doubt she provides invaluable service to her community.
-
-
Re: blessings to mj and his teacher may their work benefit many
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 9:12 AM
Those suffering from the afflictions should be treated with real consideration and care. Asking them to believe in guaranteed healing, and then to spend $2000, and then take up two weeks of their life without really being able to heal any and all inflictions is sick. Some kind of sickness where you make promises that lead to anguish and disappointment for others because you're intent on being seen as a great healer.
Is that harsh?
Maybe, but it's a lot less harsh to say it than it would be for the one headed home from such an event no better than they arrived.
Chances are you'd be told it was because of something you were doing or not doing that the healing didn't occur. -
-
Unsu...
Re: blessings to mj and his teacher may their work benefit many
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 9:45 AM"heal any and all afflictions"
is surely a tough order to fill and i would consider rewording it for sure.. -
-
healing
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 2:49 PMdefine: to heal, healing, healer
smiles to your day people -
-
Food for thought
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 3:12 PMAnd the native indian said to the white man: First you took our land and now you take our religion... -
-
Re: Food for thought
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 3:23 PMReligion comes from the land... -
-
Re: Food for thought
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 3:29 PMok if you prefer...spiritual traditions.
-
-
Re: Food for thought
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 3:24 PMBack in the days that the space program had manned flights to the moon, astronauts used to train on their equipment in the desert near Tuba City, Arizona, where the ground conditions were similar to the lunar surface.
One day, an old Navajo shepherd and his grandson were up in the hills, watching the lunar modules move across the landscape. The old man sent his grandson down to talk to these strange beings to find out what they were. "Don't be scared, son," the scientists told the boy, "these are just transportation for the people we will be sending to the moon."
The boy told his grandfather, who spoke only Navajo, that there were people down there who were going to go to the moon. At this, the old man got very excited, and told his grandson to go back down and ask if he could send a message to the moon people. The scientists thought that this would be great publicity for the space program, so they brought the old man a tape recorder, into which he spoke several words in Navajo.
When the scientists asked the grandson to translate, he refused. In fact, every Navajo they asked to translate the tape would first laugh and then refuse. Finally, one Navajo told the scientists what the old man had said: "Be careful, moon people. These white men have come to steal your land."
-- Steve
singingtotheplants.blogspot.com/ -
-
-
Unsu...
Re: Food for thought
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 3:35 PMironic that it's likely that most of the people participating in this discussion are "white"...
-
-
Re: Food for thought
Sat, May 30, 2009 - 9:48 PMSteve, correct me if I'm mistaken, but are you not an active practitioner of Amazonian style Curanderismo?
Cause uuuh, you look white in your picture......
But maybe I'm way off the mark here, in which case I apologize.
:) -
-
Re: Food for thought
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 4:50 AMJav --
I guess we could argue over whether I am an "active practitioner" and what that means. But I am without a doubt a person of pallor. I guess I don't get the point.
-- Steve
singingtotheplants.blogspot.com/ -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: Food for thought
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 5:40 AMI just thought it was odd, a story about how white men do nothing but steal, but yet you're a white guy who practices a traditional native path, and clearly have not stolen it.......
Right? I mean, the whole "white people are bad and steal your traditions" line, well, it doesn't seem to be a very productive line of reasoning in this day and age to me, but then again, I'm sure it still applies in many contexts...... -
-
Re: Food for thought
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 6:26 AMJav --
When Celeste wrote: "And the native indian said to the white man: First you took our land and now you take our religion... " it reminded me of a joke. I think the joke is pretty funny, so I shared it. Believe me, I had nothing profound in mind. :-)
But you raise an important point, which is always worth discussing. My personal view is that the greatest harm is not the theft of a tradition -- traditions, after all, borrow from each other all the time -- but rather the theft of voice. I wrote about this idea at singingtotheplants.blogspot.com/20...tml . I would be very interested in your thoughts.
-- Steve
singingtotheplants.blogspot.com/ -
-
Re: Food for thought
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 7:04 AMIt is an interesting point..
How people learn..
It is the power of the idea.. a form of magic that comes from the ancients..
It is the most natural thing.. because every being interacts with their surroundings..
It learns from the nature that surrounds it.
You can see it in small eco-systems.. How things interact and how they form a perfect circle in sustaining each other..
It has always been...
How homo-sapiens got rid of the neanderthals..
How the Greeks learned from the Egyptians. And how the Romans took over a lot of the gods and philosophy from them.
How pagan rituals still find their way in modern life..
How the words in the Bible have been interpreted, and have been re- and re-interpreted by many souls..
How democracy spreads.. as if it is the only option...
When I look at America I am struck with a feeling of dualism..
It's history is not pretty.. harsh.. full of blood and hate...
But beautiful things also... great music.. great movies... a symbol for freedom...
Inside the machine lie broken hearts..
American people need to be healed most of all..
And this post shows they grab the methods the land offers and has offered.
It learns from local history.. spirits of the land...
Because western civilisation is not natural...
What I mean... the humans that inhibit the cities are often disconnected from nature...
When the city is a habitat, the mind becomes used to this model...
That is what funny in modern culture... being street-wise.. is a model...
But when one is not aware of the model.. one becomes a model...
Instead of keeping the model as a mode...
There is a lot to say about it..
But it stays a philosophy... just another idea...
I stick to some words fom one of my heroes Lenny Bruce
Who is an American by the way..
"It is not about 'what should be'.. It's about 'what is'.."
I see a truth in there that is fundamental for freeing the mind.. -
-
Unsu...
Re: Food for thought
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 9:15 AM"American people need to be healed most of all.. "
well said. healed of our dominance and conquering mindset.
and sometimes it's other Americans, the ones who have bravely peeked out of the materialism and fundamental spiritual lethargy that can begin the process for others. but to always remember to keep old patterns in check within ourselves, and forvige others who slip up once in a while... -
-
Unsu...
Re: Food for thought
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 9:19 AMi find that happens to me all the time,
no matter how much i intend to respect and treat native plants and culture with he utmost honor,
every once in a while that little voice in me wants to change things according to what I (the BIG I) thinks is best
can't listen to that voice for too long.
that's what i mean by keeping it in check...thats all i can really do becasue i can't change where i came from.. -
-
Re: Food for thought
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 9:53 AMrebecca,
the work you have done on your own awareness shows, lady. and you are gifted at mediation i can tell by an earlier post here. very good. keep up the good work! lol
indeed we cannot change where we are from and in fact we can honor it. perhaps there is some benefit in having the perspective from this place especially once we begin to open our eyes. there is A LOT of good any of us can accomplish without much effort (some effort at least).
seems to me it all can start simply - respect and humility.
-
-
-
-
Re: Food for thought
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 5:33 PMSteve - I totally missed that you were just writing a funny anecdote and thought you were going for the deeper meaning, or making a point of sorts. Thanks for your response. I've got the article bookmarked and will read it tonight or tomorrow. Thanks again for your response.
:) -
-
Re: Food for thought
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 5:46 PMSteve - just read the article, it's brilliant man! Really makes a great and important distinction. While the concept of cultural appropriation is sometimes hard to define, stealing someone's voice is a good bit clearer and easier to understand, or rather, that really addresses the underlying topic as to why cultural appropriation can be so harmful.
Good stuff!
:)
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 4:30 PMFascinating discussion.
A few questions:
Is it cultural appropriation to have:
A white person teaching Yoga and meditation?
A Japanese person playing Western Classical music?
An indigenous Peruvian studying and then practicing Western (well, Northern) medicine?
A white person studying and performing classical Indian music or dance?
A white person playing a djembe?
An African person playing a piano?
A white person practicing acupuncture or ayurvedic medicine?
A European learning to professionally cook Thai food or becoming s professional sushi chef?
A Brazilian jungle person becoming a Catholic priest? (no judgment about Catholicism please!)
If so, why, if not, how do these things really differ from a gringo studying and then practicing curanderismo?
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 4:58 PMRichard-
Excellent and wise questions.
The people who are the keepers of the tradition are, I feel, the ones best qualified to speak on whether they feel it is cultural appropriation. And if they have given approval to this person to participate or practice, then I trust that. If not, and they have bad feelings about what he's doing, I trust that too.
They are, I feel, the ones most qualified to decide what is and isn't appropriate.
It's odd to see people that have come to the tradition as an outsider telling another outsider that they're doing it wrong. I don't get that. It actually seems sort of silly, to be honest.
My indigenous with indigenous people is that they are almost always welcoming to outsiders. But when these outsiders get "in" - or feel like they've gotten in - there tends to be an elitism toward other outsiders that I don't see with Native folks. And it usually always shows up under the guise of the "cultural appropriation" discussion.
I don't know the guy running this retreat, and don't know how his Elders feel about what he's doing. But I know it's not my place to judge him. And I admire how willingly he's answered questions and given the details of his background. Given how he was approached, I respect his replies and his tone a great deal.
Veg -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 5:00 PM> My indigenous with indigenous people...
That should (obviously) have read "My experience with indigenous people..."
Veg
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 5:36 PMLike a surgical knife, Richards questions cut cleanly through to address the heart of the matter. It is interesting how some paths we no longer even remotely consider to be cultural appropriation (yoga, ayurveda, etc...) and others we jump so quickly to assume that it is. I imagine there's a lot of historical, cultural and political reasons (and others) there to explain why we perceive as different these relations between traditions and peoples.
And Veg, as always, it's a huge pleasure to read your words:
"I don't know the guy running this retreat, and don't know how his Elders feel about what he's doing. But I know it's not my place to judge him. And I admire how willingly he's answered questions and given the details of his background. Given how he was approached, I respect his replies and his tone a great deal.
"
Aho Brother, right on the money! -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 6:58 PMThanks. One of the only things we can count on as always occurring is change. That and different cultures learning from other cultures.
It's so interesting to me that people get so upset about this stuff. I mean, if some gringo was trapsing weeks through the jungle to find an uncontacted tribe (that wouldn't kill him or her on sight!), that's one thing. But the whole of "civilized" Amazonia has had so much contact with the outside world that there really is no purity of culture left there. The Catholic church has been there for 500 years or so and there have been hundreds of years of exploitation for rubber, sugar, wood, minerals, and now oil. IMNVHO, sincere gringos going there to learn with respect and honor for the traditions are way less harmful than any of the above by a factor that approaches infinite. Besides, the people there seem to really like us and our curiosity. I'm not really into the idea of trying to go native by wearing ropa tipica as I think it looks beyond ridiculous and quite foolish, but then, what do you do if a curandero puts a feathered crown on your head or paints your face with huito? Say no? Is that respectful? Or if a Shipibo woman works for weeks to make you a ceremonial outfit, and your buying it will put food in her families belly for a few months? Say no? I know that there is one waiting for me on my next trip south that I'll buy just to help my friend who made it for me.
Anthropologists, well, a few of them, really don't like gringos being there studying the medicine. I really don't like anthropologists! Trying to understand a culture without getting their feet wet. All between the ears and never in the heart.
I wonder how many native kids in the gringo centric cities of Iquitos, Tarapoto, San Francisco Yarinacocha, Cuzco, etc. have chosen to study with their curandero(a) parent when seeing how gringos respect the tradition vs. wanting to become a computer programer or work in the oil fields or cut down trees for the hardwood industry? Now that would be an interesting antrhopological study to me.
If we believe that Ayahuasca is an intelligent entity (I sure do) than perhaps all of this is a part of her plan for world domination!!!! Just joking - well, not really - world enlightenment maybe. She's out of the jungle for the first time ever that we know of. Does she feel appropriated? Somehow I think not. In fact, I'm fairly certain in that way that you can't really explain that she really likes learning about these strange white demons, their minds, music, neurosis, etc. And she seems to love participating in healing us as well.
Just my 2 cents.
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sun, May 31, 2009 - 7:31 PM"I don't know the guy running this retreat, and don't know how his Elders feel about what he's doing. But I know it's not my place to judge him. And I admire how willingly he's answered questions and given the details of his background. Given how he was approached, I respect his replies and his tone a great deal."
veg,
i agree, i think he handled himself well given the manner he was approached. -
-
Unsu...
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 9:34 AM"Fascinating discussion.
A few questions:
Is it cultural appropriation to have:
A white person teaching Yoga and meditation?
A Japanese person playing Western Classical music?
An indigenous Peruvian studying and then practicing Western (well, Northern) medicine?..... "
i think that's a great point, but back to the original point that embrace made,
she seemed to be highlighting the WAY that the "white" guy was putting this retreat together, not the fact that he's a white guy studying Amazonian shamanism. there wasn't much info/recognitiion of his maestro (s) on the website. it initually appeared to be a little egocentric and vague, but from the further info MJ provided, we all seem to understand a little better.
but the medicine is totally a travelling/evolving being, and it's scary to think of old cultures changing and morphing so quicky in these times. but i personally feel quite drawn to be a postitive part of this change, if change must occur. i imagine many others here do too.
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 10:08 AM"but the medicine is totally a travelling/evolving being, and it's scary to think of old cultures changing and morphing so quicky in these times."
It is scary. What scares me the most is that the old wisdom is being lost. How many medicines have disapeared either from the face of the earth or from the knowledge base of the old cultures? How many songs?
But things change and will continue to do so. How many of us would change our life for the lives or our great great great grandparents? I certainly wouldn't. So who am I to say that I want certain cultures to remain fixated as they are? That is for them to say, not me. I certainly want them to have that opportunity should it be what they choose though. That's why what is happening in Peru as we type is so important. The tribal people are speaking up and closing down oil fields and refineries. Saying "enough" to pollution, destruction, and the rape of their land and people. That is the fight we should be focused on and supporting. -
-
Unsu...
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 10:16 AMAmazonistas is a great set-up for that fight...
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 10:51 AMAs is so often the case, I agree with Richard. In my training in wilderness survival, I often came across people who condemned the entire modern world. To which I had a one-word reply: modern dentistry.
I am sixty-five years old, going to be sixty-six in July. Just two generations ago, I would have been an old man. The retirement age was set at sixty-five because that was when people were used up and worn out -- toothless, disabled by injury, often in pain from degenerative diseases, and susceptible to being carried off by infection. I am glad I live today, and not two generations ago.
It is true that indigenous cultures may have healthy elders. But the percentage of their population that reaches healthy elderhood is much smaller than in our culture today.
And, as I discuss at singingtotheplants.blogspot.com/20...ml, plant knowledge inevitably disappears. The difference between a living culture and a dying culture is that a living culture replaces lost plant knowledge with new plant knowledge, but a dying culture does not, so that its knowledge base does nothing but shrink. It is, in fact, the dying culture that is static, and the living culture that changes.
-- Steve
singingtotheplants.blogspot.com/
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 10:52 AMOops. the proper address for the blog post is singingtotheplants.blogspot.com/20...tml . -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 10:53 AMOops. Modern dentistry is two words. :-) -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 11:03 AM<g>
And vitamins and other nutritional substances. And a fairly wide variety of foods. And world travel. In the past it was fairly rare for a person to experience the world more than a few miles from their home. It took tons of money and even more tons of personal risk and discomfort. I'm very happy I've had the opportunity to live and know in 4 widely different cultures and to learn their ways. One of my deepest hopes for the coming oil crisis is that new ways of non-harmful travel will be created that will continue to allow this. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 11:25 AM>>>it was fairly rare for a person to experience the world more than a few miles from their home.<<<
This is true today right here in the inner city. As I do more and more peace work with gang youth, I am struck by the fact that many have never traveled outside a single ten-block area. Taking some gang youth to downtown Chicago is like taking them to the moon. I have worked with one woman gang worker who periodically just takes high-school-age inner-city girls out to a nice restaurant -- something we take for granted, but that the girls have never experienced.
-- Steve
singingtotheplants.blogspot.com/ -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 12:27 PMYes. that is so sadly true. I used to work with a group that owned some land outside of L.A. and they occasionally brought inner city teens there for classes. Many had never seen the ocean or stars in the sky or a tree growing in nature. We're talking about 15 miles distance. -
-
Unsu...
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 1:47 PMso its not just an issue with curanderos/indiginos.
there are many who havent the opportunity to "see the world".. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 2:16 PMThere lies the heart of the druid/shaman..
Keeping people and nature together..
In old days a person would not even know what would lie 15 miles away...
In those days you had the wise one... who kept the wisdom at heart... a protector of nature including the nature in people in all it's beautiful aspects..
Times change...
Now you have airplanes with internet.....
Communication between two continents takes less then a second...
But globalisation will never take away the heart of people...
It will never oppress the power of nature....
Stil pain and disconnectedness stays... as in old days..
Marketing has taken over a sacred place... another image to believe in....
And what image do you want to fill...
And who keeps the image high...
What standards to live by...
Brainwashing gets a new meaning ....
SImply to create awareness around situations...
...is not a solution to anything...
It's the imagination of people that needs to be free...
To release the spirit of nature in them..
So they can learn to accept and forgive each other...
So beauty grows...
Politics are step two...
First the mind must be free....
Then the mind creates the politics from a new standard.....
Learning to see
Learning to forget...
Who are the great ideologists these days...
Where are the great philosophers...
Who can still make a change...
We need new ideas about this thing...
I notice many people have allergies for spirituality...
It has become a vague idea with a connotation of esoteric psychedelic hippies, fundamentalist muslims, or devout boring christians..
I see all this new-age stuff and get bored with the same old story.. it is fucking boring...
People should not make spirituality their "job" ...
They should be spiritual and lead an ordinary fucking life...
With all the beauty in it... dig it...?
Never stop learning is what I say... with an open heart and open eyes... and especially an open mind...
Enough ranting...
But I just wanted to get it of my chest...
If I don't bother you I would bother someone else with it.. and I know you people can handle it...
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 2:07 PM>>>given the manner he was approached<<<
I agree that MJ was moderately forthcoming -- I still don't know, for example, what he means when he says that he is coronado -- and he certainly gave me enough information to make a reasoned judgment about the services he was offering.
But what was wrong with the way he was approached?
He shows up in this tribe, having joined, by all appearances, solely to advertise his retreats. He had taken no part in any prior discussions, and his initial post contained no information about who he was or how he was qualified to do what he was promising to do.
So he was questioned and challenged. He was asked -- I thought politely -- about his background and training, about the way his proposed program impacted the indigenous peoples from whom it was derived, and about his claim that his maestra ayahuasquera could cure all diseases. None of this was, I think, out of line in any way.
How else should he have been approached?
-- Steve
singingtotheplants.blogspot.com/ -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 2:14 PMI think the conversation has evolved nicely, but it seemed like embrace's original response was a bit quick to judge, to me anyways. Given that initial welcome MJ could have chosen to become defensive and not respond well to the subsequent questions which were all polite and well intentioned yes, but also pointed and direct. But like I said, the conversation has evolved nicely though..... -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 3:29 PMsteve and jav,
when i say "the manner he was approached" i still do not apologize (though now i see how i dominated this guys thread), but considering the manner he was approached he faced things directly.
let's face it, we are all outsiode the culture there and no matter how welcoming the people we meet there are neither they nor even the wisest among us can know how we impact their lives. and now i read richard's post in amazonistas about the peruvian governments ambitions to offer up most or all of the amazon to be available for drilling. who knows how long the amazon we love will be as we know it?
it's geting late. there is no time to go around playing shamanism, and i don't mean that as disrespect for those of you dedicated, humble, and respectful. it's just that there is a tremendous need for us all to start thinking of them FIRST, to consider them and the jungle first before ourselves and our own interests.
you are right, jav, the thread turned out to be an interesting discussion. i pray this discussion continues in one form or another and inspires action. i did jump on him very quickly but i read his post carefully and thoroughly looked through his page before my comment so it was well thought out. and as i have said, it was not offered with ill will or without compassion. sometimes the only way to wake up is a slap in the face. sounds a bit rough but look very carefully at what he put out there and tell me where i erred.
i hope that any of us who go there for the blessings offered to us that we show the utmost gratitude and respect in some way. honor your teacher, honor their people, honor the jungle, the medicine, the knowledge. don't just take and take and hold yourself up as a result of what you have made of yourself resulting from those gifts!
i'm in no position to judge either, veg. but i took it upon myself to speak my mind and hold mj accountable. considering this he responded as directly as he could and i respect that. still not into what he's presenting. it's offensive. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 5:22 PM“there is a tremendous need for us all to start thinking of them FIRST,”
Personally, when ever I hear these words I turn around and run as fast as I can. From missionaries thinking they are saving the heathens to corporations making decisions in the name of their stockholders. In my book this is scary!
Once you let someone else do the thinking for you it’s a short road to disaster. I will never give over my life’s energy to what someone else says I should be doing.
Although I honestly praise your efforts Embrace, I feel you have adopted a few wrong headed methods to achieving your desired ends. You are attempting to use fear to motivate people towards your causes. You are asking them to give up their own voice, their own vision and their own dreams because you know what is “right”. And if they are not acting within your narrowly described path then you judge them as offensive.
If that is your intention then so be it. I offer support to each and every one to follow their own hearts, their own path, their own dreams and to find their own vision, for what in them strives, to create a world worth living in.
I do share your fears and concerns about jungles, the poor, and the disenfranchised of our world and I work towards a better tomorrow for all. And I do it from my own heart, I do it the way I am blessed to be in the world, I do it with the tools I have learned so far, ever eager to learn more. It may not be perfect in your book but its perfect in mine, and that is all I ask for.
For a better tomorrow,
David -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 5:55 PMhi david,
not sure how to respond to this because i'm not sure if i see where you are getting it. perhaps you can use quotes or bits i've written and point out to me where i'm inspiring fear and how i'm telling others to do their thinking? and especially show me what is it in what i am doing that is like missionaries and how i am asking someone to give up their own voice. could you point these things out about something here or in my pages specifically?
i have injected a sense of urgency, maybe that's what you are referring to as fear? if you are seeing something i don't please do point it out and open my eyes.
thanks. -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 7:11 PMEmbrace,
Urgency (“it's geting late, there is no time to …”) is a symptom of fear – the fear of being late. When I feel I am late I drive differently then when I feel I am ahead of time. My urgency breeds narrow-sightedness; a tendency to drive less safely in relation to others. This often implies that I consider what I am doing as more important than what you are doing.
And you are urging “that we should “start thinking of them FIRST, to consider them and the jungle first before ourselves and our own interests”. I don’t believe this type of thinking will ever truly solve any problems. I personally feel that it is through thinking about ourselves first that we begin the process of healing, the process of finding what is most important to us personally, and by extension, to us as a species and co-inhabitants on this planet. And it is from this path of discovery that we find our own vision, our own voice and our own personal expression towards a greater world for all.
And this personal expression may fit with your ideas “dedicated, humble, and respectful” “show the utmost gratitude and respect in some way. honor your teacher, honor their people, honor the jungle, the medicine, the knowledge”, or not. These all sound like great things but most likely we all have somewhat different ideas of what these words mean, and what my teacher and I consider respectful may not fit your ideas. In most cases I find judging who is doing the wrong thing all too slippery.
I understand that in light of the current state of affairs in our world that these ideas may be hard to embrace, especially considering the seemingly endless list of challenges our world is facing. But it’s my belief that very few of our planets human inhabitants are actually thinking on their own, for themselves and for their own best interests. They are sold “Save the Amazon” right next to the “New Nike Tennis Shoes” and they actually lack the connection to understand the difference between the two. To me the world needs as many people “playing shaman” as possible – two great words together at last! It’s not end point, but a beginning.
Respectfully,
David -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Mon, June 1, 2009 - 9:01 PMDavid,
Thank you, david, I appreciate your comments. I find them very interesting and enlightening. First, overall I am glad to hear all this because I certainly do not want to misrepresent Amazonistas in any way and this opens my eyes that I must be careful to make sure to distinguish my own opinion and the position of Amazonistas. I thank you for this.
So with that in mind, everything I’ve written in this thread is my opinion and not necessarily those of the organization. In fact a few people involved in the organization come to mind right away who do not agree with me on a lot. We stick to the mission statement as faithfully and honestly as we can.
Which is:
Amazonistas is the effort to educate, cooperate and participate in local, low-impact solutions for improving quality of life anywhere. We begin in the Amazon, the lungs of the world.
It is our mission to bring to public view working models for maximum self-reliance and minimum ecological impact that can inspire more of the same all over the world.
Amazonistas is not affiliated with any political or religious agendas or interests.
We advocate respect for and preservation of all life.
Amazonistas is your support for educational, ecological and humanitarian endeavors. It is a resource and online platform for those of you working together in the Amazon and beyond.
It is designed to be for you or anyone to get clothing and basic supplies like pencils, and so much we take for granted that is incredibly meaningful for a child down there. The educational projects are collaborations, we find out what the needs are in a place, like San Filipe for example, where the tiny population are cultivating medicine plants and have built a five bed healing retreat called “Quando las plantas nos hablan” when the plants speak to us. Which supports their little community of three hundred and also thereby provides all their health care (a great place to go for natural plant healing and support the community by doing so). They requested the resources and assistance to address their waste and water situation.
I’m curious, David, what you would personally do to benefit these people in some way if they asked you about waste and water? We didn’t ask them, they asked us. If it was you and they asked you, what would you suggest?
There is a rainwater and grey water reclamation education and training project in the works. Money, energy, and plastic are involved in getting drinking water in a lot of places we went to. Not everyone has the money to build a tank. We support educational projects that teach people to design, build and train others utilizing accessible, sustainable resources. (anyone interested: contact@amazonistas.org)
Think about it, what is to be done with plastic in the Amazon?
By respect I mean for example, try not to let ones “voice” trump the voice of the maestro, your teacher. Respect for the teacher, the knowledge, and the plants. Does that sound like it runs counter to your values?
“show the utmost gratitude and respect in some way. honor your teacher, honor their people, honor the jungle, the medicine, the knowledge”, or not. These all sound like great things but most likely we all have somewhat different ideas of what these words mean, and what my teacher and I consider respectful may not fit your ideas.”
Very good point. I mean respect in the most basic sense as in courtesy:
respect in the dictionary -
3.esteem for or a sense of the worth of a person, a personal quality or ability, or something considered as a manifestation of a personal quality or ability: I have great respect for her judgment.
4.deference to a right, privilege, privileged position, or someone or something considered to have certain rights or privileges; proper acceptance or courtesy; acknowledgment: respect for a suspect's right to counsel; to show respect for the flag; respect for the elderly.
5.the condition of being esteemed or honored: to be held in respect.
Humility as in not bombastic like me. As in putting your maestros name out there if that is where people are being invited to go. It’s her place? That wasn’t conveyed very clearly. To me, that alone demonstrates disrespect. Not sure why this offends your sensibilities, does it?
So, David, what would you do about waste disposal and clean drinking water in the Amazon? Where do you go when you go? What is your experience there? You make very good points.
“Urgency (“it's geting late, there is no time to …”) is a symptom of fear – the fear of being late. When I feel I am late I drive differently then when I feel I am ahead of time. My urgency breeds narrow-sightedness; a tendency to drive less safely in relation to others. This often implies that I consider what I am doing as more important than what you are doing.”
Excellent point. Thank you.
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Tue, June 2, 2009 - 11:31 AMInteresting, interesting. I can't help smiling when here in the Ecuadorian Amazon a group of gringo shaman apprentices with necklaces and bracelets from seeds and teeth in rclothes from Otavalo comes back from a trip to a sacred power spot, exchanging words in Quichua they have learned, smelling like jungle, fire and Ayahuasca, and suddenly they meet a group of young indigenous Kichwa, similar but clothed in the western fashion, hair full of grease, perfumed, with their cellulars playing loud dance music, not knowing enough kichwa to understand :-) The look in their eyes, I wonder whats running in their head. In other words, I feel that giving example is very important. Showing interest too.
(Richard, I love your story about the White people stealing the Mars people their land :-)) -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Tue, June 2, 2009 - 1:51 PMI remember coming down (geographically and cosmonautically) back into Cusco after a beautiful long day of dancing with Huachuma, and here I am, wide pupils, wearing a beautiful Cusco made poncho, and a couple of other gringos were too.....but I'm just a pretend gringo, I look like one but am Chilean and speak fluent Spanish. So when some kids walked by they were all giggling to each other about the Gringos dressed like Peruanos.......so I approached them, and laughed with them a little bit about us silly gringos....and then pointed out to them that they were wearing sneakers, baseball hats, t-shirts and jeans....all Gringo wear. Heehee.....I was the only one that kept on laughing! ;) -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Tue, June 2, 2009 - 3:22 PMVery nice you guys - its a crazy world to be sure. And a crazy world to love.
D
-
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Tue, June 2, 2009 - 3:20 PMHi Embrace,
Once again I praise you for your love and energy in forming Amazonistas and in no way do my comments relate to Amazonistas and your work there. I remember that you mentioned that you don’t believe you have done very much but truly you have. You are a conduit for a great and loving vision and you have materialized this powerful vision with words that have the potential of reaching millions of people in our world and changing reality on a very large scale. Please do not undervalue your contributions or compare them to anyone else. You are the voice for many.
I believe we share many of the same values, respect, humility, gratitude. We do have slightly different expressions, and I believe different expressions actually create much of the beauty we find in our world. Indeed our expressions such of ideas, respect, honor, and humility, might be even more different than we imagine.
Yes, there were a few things that MJ wrote that raised questions including his not mentioning the name of his teacher. I’m not sure why this was omitted and I’m not sure that it lacks respect. Perhaps he had been asked not to mention his maestros name, perhaps he thought that an American audience would be more accessible with the words he used, and yes perhaps he got caught in the traps that we have all fallen into where we loose perspective and humility. I guess my point is that we don’t know until we ask and making assumptions most likely leads to defending them, a stance we often avoid if we approach the matter with curiosity rather than anger. Wrong assumptions often puts people on the defensive which is usually an aggressive stance. I must commend MJ that his defense was quite reasonable, and in my book the best proof so far that his heart is in the right place.
The same goes for his statement "heal any and all afflictions". I find this rather enthusiastic to say the least and I am curious with questions more that offended. Part of me empathies with this his enthusiasm even though my reality is perhaps more tempered.
As to your questions:
I have many ideas about water and waste in the Amazon, Peru or any developing country. And when I say “I have many ideas” please understand that I believe all ideas are universal. To me ideas are gifts, they float around like radio signals until someone with the particularly shape antenna receives them – often many people at one time. I don’t own ideas that come to me and they are of very little value until they take a material manifestation. The mastery of idea manifestation is certainly valuable but it too is a gift, and quickly becomes useless or even harmful if the source is forgotten. You have demonstrated that gift of in forming Amazonistas, a beautiful manifestation indeed.
When you ask “Think about it, what is to be done with plastic in the Amazon?” I immediately think about plastic bags. The larger reality of what to do with plastic in the Amazon poses the same question we are asking ourselves about what to do with plastic in our world. It certainly is a crazy tangled mess we have created.
I am always struck by the complexity of plastic bags in Peru. Here are people who have, since time immemorial, thought of the river as both the provider and the acceptor. Tradition is to throw all waste into the river, and until recently, the river it played its part with out much fuss. But now plastic bags in rivers are the cause of much despair from the glacial agricultural field of the Cordillera Blanca, where they block stone irrigation canals, to the Amazon basin. We are talking about changing the way people have been living and thinking for thousands of years. And with that we are asking them to change the way they see their world, a world where everything was connected, to a world where some things are better left out. To me this is quite complex because these new ideas bring with them the energy and thought processes of the “civilized” world. The energy of “some things are better left out” is the very energy of separateness, the energy that many of us are hoping to change back to what we all once understood to be the energy of connection. It’s a double edged sword, another complex twisted mess of realities.
So many cities and countries are banning plastic bags that it really makes sense that this should happen in Peru and other South American countries.
www.planetark.org/dailynews.../story.htm
Certainly they have the right to benefit from the lessons we have learned even more than the mistakes we have made.
I don’t know much about making rubber but isn’t the Amazon the home of latex? Can’t rubber be used to line wooden barrels or baskets and used to store water? It seems like a long shot but there may be opportunities to actually use latex for the betterment of local societies.
I know even less about waste but I do know that you can drink your pee:
brittaandrebecca.org/drinkpee/
compost your shit:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composting_toilet
www.aselfsufficientlife.com/comp....html
www.jenkinspublishing.com/sawdu...t.html
and drink gray water:
www.builditsolar.com/Project...ater.htm
All of these are just ideas and mean very little without manifestation and I understand that the people whom we are talking about are extremely poor. I can count on my hands the number of hours I have spent in Lower Belen and I found it both fascinating and frightening. The extent and depth of poverty is as dramatic as any I have ever experienced and yet I sensed a warmth not found on our own streets.
Many tourist visit Belen Market and stand looking down at the stairs to Lower Belen but very few actually visit this area and its people.
Another idea would be to get your Amazonista site listed on the websites of major Iquitos hotels and restaurants. Maybe work a deal where visitors receive a modest discount on food or services if they bring a suitcase of school goods or cloths. Or even work with LAN Airlines to see if they will put a link to your site on their website and offer discounts on extra luggage to Iquitos if it is for Amazonista.
I wish I had more time to spend on this and other wonderful visions but I am forced as we all are to choose “my brightest diamond”; the one vision I feel most passionate about (which of course saving the world in my own way). Its certainly a complex world and it often takes all of us playing together to make any sense of it.
Best wishes,
David -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Tue, June 2, 2009 - 4:24 PMvery glad i asked! thank you david! and good points yet again.
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Tue, June 2, 2009 - 4:29 PMThat's a whole lot to read, but then again, I'm kind of a lazy interneter, don't usually read very long posts. But I did notice this:
"When you ask “Think about it, what is to be done with plastic in the Amazon?” I immediately think about plastic bags. The larger reality of what to do with plastic in the Amazon poses the same question we are asking ourselves about what to do with plastic in our world. It certainly is a crazy tangled mess we have created. "
And this came to mind:
Around here some friends of mine who are into bio-construction, you know adobe, cob, etc...will fill plastic bottles as tight as possible with other pieces of trash, plastic bags, doritos bags, whatever, just stuff em full of useless plastic trash. Then they take those bottles and put 'em in the middle of adobe walls. It adds insulation, lessens the amount of material you need to build with, gives the wall added flexibility, and allows you to make a great use of trash in a way that's beautiful and where you never see it.....
Just wanted to throw that out there as a possibility....
:) -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Tue, June 2, 2009 - 5:04 PMThat's creative!
There's a lot of use for plastic bottles and bags other than as river waste. I just bought some felt fabric for wrapping my flutes that is made 100 percent from recycled plastic bottles.
But speaking of Belen, I have spent some time at the bottom end of the steps. When I look at what is going on there, it seems nearly hopeless. Out houses that empty directly into the river, people next to the toilets drinking water and bathing. So much plastic garbage that i think it would take months just to clean it all up. And that's just what hasn't washed down the river. It would take a huge influx of money and time just to let people know that there is alternatives. More money and time then that by far to create them. But that's just a small part of the problem. Factories that empty their toxic wastes directly into the river, mercury from gold mining, God knows what from oil companies. All going into the Amazon or it's tributaries. You may not know, but there's more unique species of aquatic life in the Amazon than there is in the Atlantic Ocean. And not too long ago it was pristine. But then there are rivers in the U.S. now that 50 years ago a lit match would set on fire. Now they are full of fish, and while not drinkable, are pretty health ecosystems. Really, a good recycling plant in Iquitos that paid a couple pennies a bottle would get people collecting the plastic like crazy. But plastic bags . . . those should be illegal everywhere. We survived for a very long time without them and could do so again. And then there's Styrofoam cups, bowls and plates - half life of a billion years those suckers have.
I was in India a very long time ago. Plates were made out of leaves, cups were ceramic, pots for yogurt were hand thrown next to the yogurt stand and then filled with milk, covered with a leaf and tied with a string. When you ate the yogurt the clay was recycled for new pots. It made so much sense. Not it's all done in plastic, which gets burned in bonfires, filling the air with toxic smoke.
We're not very sensible creatures.
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 8:05 AMJust a quick response, I dont know why you say that I havent said my teachers name, I wrote it down a couple of times in this topic, and written on my web page as well, but since it was missed, her name is Dona Othelia, and she lives on KM 50. If you want to read about somebody's healing journey with her, her blog can be found here: lakshmishealingjourney.blogspot.com/search/label/March%202008 Lakshmi is a real inspiration for me. As for my saying that Dona Othelia can heal any and all afflictions, she cas cured many ailments and health concerns. If you dont like those words, then what do you suggest I change them to? Perhaps I will change it to many afflictions... Im sure than many curandero's can make similar claims as well, if they are true maestros... I have met many there who have cured cancer, aids, herpies, MS, and many other so called incurable diseases, and other minor problems as well. Othelia is truely a gifted healer, and I want to share my experiences with her with others. The whole intent for this retreat is to share her gifts with others, but at the same time, to add to those experiences with my own. I know that many are interested in learning about shamanism and shamanic healing techniques, and I have some experience with it that I want to share by adding a couple of workshops to the mix, so to speak. I dont see myself being any different than some of the other retreats offered. Some include yoga, chakra balancing, etc... Mine includes learning about medicine wheels, power animals, and assemblage points.
To make another point, it ws suggested that I joined this site just to plug my retreat, but if any of you have looked at the date I joined, the exact date is March 25th... I made this post 2 months after the fact, and in truth, I only had the idea to put this retreat together about 3 weeks before, where I started to create the web page that I was using. Yes, I am a fairly new person on this forum... you know, it kind of remimds me of when I was growing up. My father was in the military, so I was always moving, about every 3 years. I was always the new kid in school, and was treated poorly. You know how you treated the new kid in school... well, that was me. This fourm feels like the same to me, but I am used to it. It does not trouble me to be accused of being egotistical, a fake, using my teacher, taking advantage of the indigenous community, and all of the other things mentioned here. I wont bother responding to these accusations. This post is about the retreat. It is not about me, but about you and your healing. Let me say that again, it is about YOU and YOUR HEALING. I am merely giving an extra hand. Lets keep that in mind, that this is about YOU. Again, her name is Dona Othelia, in case you glossed over it again. If you have a problem with that, then thats fine. You dont have to join the retreat. If you have a problem with me using the chakapa, the didjeridoo, my crystals, fans, and other healing instruments that I was trained to use, then thats fine too. I dont care if you aprove or not, that is YOUR problem. Dont try to make it mine, or make me feel that what I am doing is wrong. Now after reading this over, I realize that I am being a bit defensive and im sure that quotes will be made to argue with me, that my ego is just huge, etc... Well, think about it like this. Its hard to show whether I am egotistical, vain, conceited, or whatever just through writing these words. All of you have not spoken to me personally, or know what my personality is like. In shamanism, or at least what I am leaning about and have been taught, we are all mirrors to eachother. When you are frustrated with another, or angry, or whatever, if you just take a step back, you can see how your feelings of the other person has more to do with yourself than with the other person. Remember, those are YOUR feelings you are projecting onto another. Examine those thoughts and feeling. Can you see them in yourself? Can you see how you are egotistical? Careless? Thoughtless? Etc... Perhaps if you can see that in yourself, and even if a person acts in a way that is considered to be angry, egotistical, vain, or even stupid, careless, or whatever, we can all treat others with more compassion and care, and know that it is their own feelings that they are having. They dont have to affect yourself, only if you allow it. This is the journey that I am learning about, and being mindful of others thoughts and feelings, noticing my reactions and feeling towards another, and seeing how they reflect my own self back to me. An excellent teacher, if you allow yourself to do that. To quote a friend, lets remember love, peace and harmony... help me to make it a reality. All you have to do is smile back at me... Peace on you all -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 8:43 AMCool. I've heard good things about dona Othelia.
Just a suggestion - to gain credibility here, join in on other discussions or start them yourself. It's a pretty interesting and knowledgable crew here - some with decades of experience. Put up some pictures on your page. Having someone post as 'MJ" with no pictures and no friends doesn't do a lot for credibility - so start asking people to be part of their network as well.
I personally don't care what you call yourself. Shamanic coach? Well, whatever that means. I personally find terms like "shamanic practitioner" to be stranger than strange. What's it mean? Who started it? Why use it instead of saying what you really do? You're either a healer or not. In the culture you are studying, "chaman" is not a traditional work, as I'm sure you know.
I know the origin of "shamanic practitioner" is from Michael Harner. But some people are following what he said a bit too much. Of course on the other side there's people who think they are shamans just cause they wear their hair in a certain way and have cool beads and tattoos and read a few books and took a two week seminar. That's silly, of course. So in my opnion, if you're doing healing work, if you've put in the knocks and traveled the hell realms entailed in being healed, if your maestra has given you her blessings to do the work, nothing wrong in saying what you are.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 8:14 AMI dont know what you mean by coronado... Perhaps you can lead me to where I wrote that, because I dont really think I did. Curandero, is that what you ment to write? If that is the case I NEVER claimed that. The only thing I wrote was that I am a shamanic practicioner, that I am becomming a shamanic coach, that I have learned about shamanism for the past 10 years, and that I took the ayahuayra curandero initiation program recently... And just a point, I have no problem in the way in which I was received for this post. Quite frankly, im suprized that this post has received as many posts as it has. It certinally has created a lively discussion. GIVER! I certinally tried to answer all questions asked to the best of my ability... -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 9:07 AM
I actually enjoyed your last posts MJ. There's still a few questions in my mind, a few things I'd want to continue to discuss, but you seem more relaxed and open.
I have no issue with how you dress or with which implements you use, I never have had any with that. When I play basketball I dress like a baller, and when I go into ceremony with Aya, which I do a lot of, I do it in a funny uniform. I dress for different occasions in lots of different ways.
I do feel like you need to be more considerate of how you state what healing is and what people can expect to accomplish.
Saying "any and all afflictions" is not even close to reasonable (in my opinion). I would refer to Dona Othelia and make sure that she is comfortable with whatever statements your making on her behalf, now that you've been clear that she's the one doing the healing work. A clear definition of your work and her work, with each of you describing what you do without you making general claims on her behalf would go over well I think.
I understand and appreciate your conversation about reflecting our feelings onto others, but until you've achieved some kind of true enlightened state, you don't get to say to someone it's all yours (the feelings their having) and has nothing to do with me. You see if you do that your saying the person is only ever dealing with themselves, which if true would include you in the definition of their Self.
You are connected you see, an rather than avoid feeling connected to what people are feeling about you by saying it has nothing to do with you, you could Embrace their feelings as part of your larger connected Self in the world, and honor the particular reflection coming to you by welcoming it and dancing with it and maybe even falling in live with it and starting a family, (or tribe). :)
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 9:31 AMwell, let me clairify my statement them. When I say that the feelings that the other person is is having is theirs, I mean that they own their feelings... it is their feeling they have, not somebody elses. Lets take for example two people... One is angry. That person has the feeling of being angry. The other person can realize that the other person is angry and know that they dont have to be angry themselves. This person is responsible for themselves, and they dont have to respond in kind by being angry themselves. There is nothing that person can do about the other angry person. They will either like him, or dislike him, either be friends with him, or be enemies with them. This person has no control on how the other angry person reacts, they only have control over how they themselves react. If you react in a particular way to the other person, or the other person pisses you off, or whatever, I see this as a guage and mirror of the self. It a way to see how centred you are, or off centred you are, and how to learn from this reaction/interaction. Their temperment and feelings are their own, and how they are feeling doesnt have much to do with me, it is just their reaction to me. The Dali Lama is the best example of peace and harmony, but he really pisses off the Chinese. That is their reaction to the things he says, but I think that if they can just step back and not be afraid of his ideas, perhaps a better outcome can be made. Their reaction is not found in a place of centeredness, they are just reacting. Is this making any better sense? Im not very good with words... Anyways, you make a good point, and good suggestions for me. Thank you. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 10:12 AM
Nice post MJ.
Thanks for bringing another healer into the mix. Here's a bit from him from his book, Ethics for a New Millennium, that I think relates to our discussion.
"If the self had intrinsic identity, it would be possible to speak in terms of self-interest in isolation from others. But because this is not so, because the self and others can only be understood in terms of relationship, we see that self-interest and others interest are closely interrelated. Indeed, within this picture of dependently originated reality, we see that there is no self-interest completely unrelated to others interest.
Due to the fundamental interconnectedness which lies at the heart of reality, your interest is also my interest. From this, it becomes clear that "my interest and "your" interest are intimately connected. In a deep sense, they converge.
The concept dependent origination compels us to take the reality of cause and effect with utmost seriousness. By this I mean the fact that particular causes lead to particular effects, and that certain actions lead to suffering while others lead to happiness. It is in everybody's interest to do what leads to happiness and avoid what leads to suffering. But because, as we have seen, our interests are inextricably linked, we are compelled to accept ethics as the indispensable interface between my desire to be happy and yours.
From, Dependent Origination and the Nature of Reality,
Chapter Three, page 35.
His Holiness the Dalai Lama.
-
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 10:01 AMMJ --
I am not at all sure this is worth pursuing, but you have raised the issue. You said that you had "completed the ayahuayra curandero initiation program." In the Upper Amazon, the initiation of a curandero takes a particular form, usually -- but not always -- involving the transfer of phlegm from the master to the initiate. The ceremony is often called a coronacion, and the initiate is then said to be coronado.
When you said you had "completed the ayahuayra curandero initiation program," I assumed you meant something like this -- that you had in fact been initiated in the traditional manner. I apologize if my assumption was incorrect. But I did ask you to elaborate. On May 30, I wrote: "I would also like to learn about the Ayahuayra curandero initiation -- how were you initiated? what healing techniques did you learn? what plant medicines do you use?" When you did not respond, I was perfectly happy to let it be.
Just one added point. You say that you did not join this tribe to plug your retreat. Yet it appears that, on May 28, 2009, you made precisely the same post, announcing your services, on the following tribes at the indicated times:
Ayahuasca 11:35 am
dmt 11:42 am
Ethnobotany 11:53 am
Terrence [sic] McKenna - Amazon DreamTime 11:55 am
I may be incorrect, and I would be happy to be set straight, but it appears that in each one of those cases, your announcement was the first post you had ever made in that tribe, and you had participated in no earlier discussions. That looks like advertising to me.
Now, there is absolutely nothing wrong with making an announcement of a good or service that might be of interest to members of a particular tribe. I think most people welcome such informational posts. But, as Richard has noted, when such an announcement is your *only* interaction with the tribe, it does give an appearance of being exploitative rather than helpful.
I wish you all the best with your retreats and on your journey.
-- Steve
singingtotheplants.blogspot.com/
-
-
Unsu...
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 10:29 AMOne thing in the forefront of my mind right now is how in this tradition,
there's really no way of knowing for sure whether or not a curandero is "credible" unless you hear many many things about them from people you trust,
or if you take the gamble and sit in ceremony with them to find out...
then there's the option of completely dissecting them and everything they say and let them defend themselves to the bitter end on an online forum.
i personally have gained alot of respect for MJ in this discussion and dont blame him for feeling a little irritated. it seems a little unfair to me,
and so what if he joined the forum just to promote his retreat?
i know we get tired of seeing "just another white guy" doing what so many others do, but maybe we can find a way to make decisions about someone's credibility and remain optimistic about the fact that they actually COULD be doing GREAT things and have an AWESOME background, etc...
-
-
Unsu...
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 10:38 AM...give them the benefit of the doubt, i mean.
i know it's not really the peruvian way, but we're of another culture anyway..
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 10:39 AMYes.
Nothing wrong with white, black, purple polkadoted or paisley guys, gals, mixed-gender, or aliens doing the work as long as they have a heart in the right place and are highly respectful of the tradition that they are learning/experiencing/teaching.
Here are the details of the initiation program: www.iganicsoundsystem.com/Audio...SC.htm
Certainly looks interesting. 6 weeks with 11 ceremonies. They do have an apprentice program that is 6 months long. Certainly a short time by Amazonian standards, where two years of dieta is considered the minimum. But a whole lot can be learned in 6 months.
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 10:50 AMOK, now I get it. No, never received the glob of phlegm from either of the curandero's I learned from... The initiation program, run throught the ayahuasca foundation, is a precursor to an apprecticeship with one of the curanderos that one can study with... I just happed to like Dona Othelia the best. If you want to read more about it, this is the program itself... www.ayahuascafoundation.org/Init...C.htm Healing techniques learned would include soplaying, using the chakapa, observing the making of floral baths and assisting with making ayahuasca, and learning icaros and singing them during ceremony. Since then, Plant medicines that I personally used were many, unfortunately I dont really remember the name of some of them... One was aho sacha (spelling?), and another like it, but made from a different plant... cant remember the name of it, and another very powerful purgative. Again, I cant remember the name of it, it just took me out for the whole day... There were others as well...
And As for the other part, I was just trying to make the point that I originally did not join this forum to advertise my retreat, as I had not even the thought to create one, but after deciding to organize a retreat with my flavor, so to speak, I thought that posting it here would be a good idea, as well on a few other tribes, just as many have done before me. So, no, I didnt join this tribe originally to post my retreat, as I had joined well before that time, but yes, I had made my first posts to advertise my retreat. I enjoyed just rreading the posts before, and didnt really feel like posting anything. It is not my intention on giving the impression of being exploitative, I am just getting the word out. Really, this post could have been quite different in that nobody could have made any responses, so im kind of suprized that there was such a reaction. Anyways, as I said before, either the people here are interested in the retreat, or not. Im just offering my service and help to those who wish it through this retreat.. with Dona Othelia. She is the true healer, im just offering some other workshops to make the reatreat more fun and interesting. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 11:09 AMThank you Richard and Rebecca for your comments, and all others. I have recently updated my web page, added a couple of otehr links... Looking at other sites that offer apprecticeship programs, it seems that drinking 60 times seems to be about the average before one can become a ceremonial leader, or healer, or whatever you want to call it. Sure, the program is only 6 months, shorter than the 2 years that most diet, but as mentioned, alot can be learned from drinking 60 times. I myself would love to do that, but my wife would never let me go there for 6 months... A few weeks at a time, sure, when I am able to... Anyways, im just following my dream and turning it into reality instead of just talking about it... Walk the walk, not just talk the talk, as they say. I hope that whether anybody joins this retreat or not will at least honor, or respect my efforts instead of slamming me for it just because I am new to this particular forum. -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.Unsu...
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 11:19 AMsounds like this is a learning experience for you, MJ... -
-
Unsu...
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 11:35 AMand yah, 6 months is a good start for an apprenticeship...
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 11:36 AMlol... it sure is. and working on the workshops that I will be doing... I intend on doing a couple of trial runs here where I live (which is in Calgary now) and practice a bit before the retreat. I was an english teacher for 9 years (in Japan and Canada), and I remember the first time I began teaching. Quite nervous, afraid that I was doing a poor job, and all of that, but jumping right in is the best way, for me anyways... My shamanic teacher here is incouraging me on... my final year of my program with her is mainly all practical, going into the community to teach, heal and practice my craft, so I just took it one step further to do this retrat. Some have asked a bit more about my background, I was also in the militia, so I also learned leadership skills through the 3 years of doing that. 10 years of practicing my skills with shamanism is enough. Time to share what I know. I have had a lot of life experience with my short life so far. Some people hate getting older, I look forward to it. Every year is better than the last. I have much more to learn, but I enjoy teaching and helping others. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 3:04 PMHi all,
I have been following this thread and inserted the "And the Native Indian said to the white man ...." which was btw loosely taken from the documentary 'White Shamans and Plastic Medicine Men'. No offence meant.
Anyways, that is not what I wanted to talk about. After reading people's comments about MJ and having him explain himself etc. I'm surprised nobody has asked the colour of his underwear....and I'm starting to ask myself: What do we all want from MJ? Why all this steam rolling and encouragement with mixed feelings? I admit I thought ...Oh no, another white shaman, just what the world needs.
But why? Why are so many of us so suspicious? MJ could tell us ad nauseum how many plants he has dietado, how many years experience he has and put up loads of photos on his page.
Would he be more credible then?
Are there a set rigid rules to follow when it comes to this forum to gain people's approval as a shaman or shamanic practitioner (does it really matter what it's called)?
I understand that people are curious about a 'new' shaman and want to know more about his experience but after reading the posts it seems he really has to prove himself to you lot.
Are you the enlightened ones that he has to convince?
What comes into mind is what an old shaman in Peru told me: The gringos discuss too much instead of just putting their egos aside and feel with their hearts.
I'd say: Look into MJ's eyes and find all the answers to your questions.
Con mucho amor,
Celeste
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 3:40 PMin the spirit of asking rather than making assumptions, mj, why is it you list Michael Harner's Institute of Shamanic Studies much before Dona Othelia's name?
on your page you say - "It is my intent to add to Dona Othelia's healing ceremonies and plant remedies with providing additional education in how to apply practical shamanic techniques to further facilitate balance and wholeness. " please explain why it would be necessary to "add" anything to dona othelia's work? does that then mean without the addition her work is lacking in some way?
please explain to me why her name is so far down and easily missed on your page about bringing people to her place for her curandisma. why is your promotion of a trip to see her appear to be only about you?
please explain these things. you don't mention dona othelia's name in this tribe post, why?
do you know cpr?
thank you for taking the time to respond. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 3:48 PMembrace - I don't know if all the good work you do, which for all I know is infinite, gives you the right to be the ayahuasca sherriff and ride MJ's ass like this. Now, realistically, I'm on your side and see where your coming from.....but the way you harp on him seems to have a faint air of self-righteousness to it......just saying...... -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 3:49 PMHow about we start a thread where everyone defends their right to talk about ayahuasca, and explain why our opinion or our knowledge is greater than that of the other tribe members...... -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 3:57 PMThat is a good idea... lets call the post "Colosseum" . -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 4:37 PMI'm really of two minds about all this. I've read the whole thread, and typed up responses at various times that I deleted because I knew the humor and sarcasm would be misconstrued as meanspiritedness.
My initial reaction to white shamans is revulsion. Maybe thats because someone told me that shamanism is the new yoga a few years ago, and pointed out all the bland American homogenization that occurs when white people try to incorporate indigenous traditions. For a long time I've looked at the word 'shaman' as almost an insult, as no self-respecting healer would self-apply such a clearly out of context term (provided they're not from Siberia).
I have to say though, this discussion has given me much food for thought. Jav and Richard both gave really interesting perspectives on all this... in hindsight, I can distinctly remember the pain it caused me when I'd see Peruvians and Bolivians adopting all the crassest and most materialistic aspects of Western culture. When I worked with children with the organization www.mundodeania.org , a big part of what I was doing was encouraging them to see the value in their own culture and traditions. Maybe them seeing a bunch of gringos dressed up as curanderos could be a step in the right direction... I'd never thought of it that way until Jav mentioned it.
Everything I read about Michael Harner's shamanistic practitioner program underwhelms me to the point of nausea, so I'm not going to go into that at all. However, I don't think its fair to throw the baby out with the bath water. As Richard said, ALL people, regardless of race, gender, or creed, should be allowed to follow their heart and heal. I guess the issue is when they appropriate another culture without showing respect for their teachers, or helping promote the practitioners that actually come from it.
MJ seems like a decent dude, though nothing about his retreat remotely appeals to me. You're lucky, MJ, to have so much feedback on your marketing and presentation, hopefully you'll follow alot of the advice so that you can come across as genuine as you seem to feel about this material. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 4:49 PM"Everything I read about Michael Harner's shamanistic practitioner program underwhelms me to the point of nausea, so I'm not going to go into that at all."
This may be the most beautiful sentence I've read in a while...... -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 6:28 PMGets the prize of the month!
-
-
-
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 5:17 PM"embrace - I don't know if all the good work you do, which for all I know is infinite, gives you the right to be the ayahuasca sherriff and ride MJ's ass like this."
it definitely doesn't, jav. and yes, i can be very self-righteous. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 5:34 PM"it definitely doesn't, jav. and yes, i can be very self-righteous. "
Oh. Well.....ok then.....heehee....
:) -
-
-
Unsu...
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 3, 2009 - 7:22 PM"MJ seems like a decent dude, though nothing about his retreat remotely appeals to me. You're lucky, MJ, to have so much feedback on your marketing and presentation, hopefully you'll follow alot of the advice so that you can come across as genuine as you seem to feel about this material. "
I feel the same way. I didn't detect anything out of integirty (atleast according to my personal values) in his original post, but it surely didn't jump out at me nor did it create much interest in the retreat itself.
It's just that there are so many people doing the same thing here, a little healthy competitive marketing skills can really come in handy if he really wants people to come to this thing.
not that i know anything about that.
how many people do you have signed up, MJ, if you don't mind me asking?
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Thu, June 4, 2009 - 8:26 AMI have only just recently started to send out the message about this retreat... Less than a week on this site, only 2 days in a magazine, and later I will be placing some flyers in some of the local shops where I live. I will also be giving a presentation in 2 weeks time about my experiences in Peru and the use of medicinal plants found there... So, so far I dont have anybody who has signed up yet, but it is still early and the message has only recently gone out. Yes, I am thankful for all of the feedback, and have changed and added some info. to my web site. I am passionate about this retreat and I trust that what I am offering will appeal to those who would be interested in learning about how to journey and meet their power animals and guides, to learn about medicine wheels, and a fun topic, assemblage points. Many of the other retreats offered do not have such workshops, if any at all, or at least the topics that I am presenting. So, I put my trust and my strong belief in the Great Spirit of life that my message will reach those who are interested in this retreat. -
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, June 13, 2009 - 8:41 AMIm just currious, but has anybody here visited or heard of dona Othelia, or the ayahuasca foundation? -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Sat, June 13, 2009 - 8:54 AMYes - heard of both. -
-
-
Re: an organized retreat to Peru...
Wed, June 24, 2009 - 8:47 AMJust wanted to let everybody know that I had added a date to the retreat, September 12 to 27.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-